New Years Eve Holiday Menu

Monday, December 31st

SPARKLING WINE

DI MARIA PROSECCO DOC

$30 Bottle

6 Glasses

RUINART ROSE CHAMPAGNE

$85 Bottle

6 Glasses

HORS D’OEUVRES

GRILLED CHICKEN SATAY

$32 Dozen

With thai peanut dip
Serves 3-4/Gluten-Free

SESAME SHREDDED CHICKEN

$36 Dozen

With green chili in chive crepe bundles
Serves 3-4/Gluten-Free

SEARED SESAME-CRUSTED AHI TUNA SKEWERS

$35 Dozen

With lemon ponzu dip
Serves 3-4/Gluten-Free

TERIYAKI GLAZED FILET OF BEEF KABOBS

$35 Dozen

With hot & sweet gingered chilies
Serves 3-4/Gluten-Free

SALMON TARTARE BABY WONTON CUPS

$35 Dozen

Serves 3-4

CHEVRE CROSTINI

$32 Dozen

With honeyed grape & pistachio
Serves 3-4

SLICED SHRIMP & CUCUMBER CANAPES

$35 Dozen

With dill butter
Serves 3-4/Gluten-Free

PROSCIUTTO CROSTINI

$32 Dozen

With fig-onion conserve & candied lemon
Serves 3-4

THAI SHIITAKE SATAY

$32 Dozen

With spicy peanut sauce
Serves 3-4/Vegan, Gluten Free

MINI POTATO LATKES

$39 Dozen

With smoked salmon & crème fraîche
Serves 3-4/Gluten-Free

TRUFFLE MUSHROOM RISOTTO BALLS

$32 Dozen

Serves 3-4

FRESH COD CAKES

$36 Dozen

With beet and fennel with apple horseradish sauce
Serves 3-4

PIGS IN BLANKETS

$26 Dozen

With deli mustard
Serves 3-4

COCKTAIL PLATTERS

CUBED CHEESE CRATE

$75 ea.

With fruit & savory crisps
Serves 6-10

VEGETABLE CRUDITÉ CRATE

$65 ea.

With fresh herb dip
Serves 8-12

CANAPE PLATTER

$185 ea.

With crab salad in cherry tomatoes, curry chicken salad on cucumber crisps, roast beef & horseradish cream crostini, smoked salmon triangles, lavash spirals with hummus
Serves 10-20

TUSCAN ANTIPASTO PLATTER

$155 sm. / $225 lg. each

With assorted italian meats & cheeses, grilled zucchini, peppers & artichoke skewers, eggplant caponata, pesto, olives, herbed bruschetta
Small Serves 6-10, Large 10-20

MEDITERRANEAN TAPAS PLATTER

$235 ea.

With prosciutto & pear slices, potato tortilla española, stuffed lemony grape leaves, saffron-shallot & sherry shrimp, steamed asparagus, watermelon, feta & mint skewers, caprese picks, citrus herb olives & romesco sauce
Serves 10-20

CELEBRITY CELEBRATION PLATTER

$235 ea.

With smoked salmon spirals with scallion cream cheese, steamed asparagus, honey pecan chicken skewers, shrimp cocktail, tenderloin beef biscuits with horseradish cream & baby arugula, cocktail sauce, truffled aïoli, cheese straws
Serves 10-20

DESSERT

MINIATURE DESSERT PASTRIES

$38 Dozen

Bite-sized fruit tarts, mini mousse tarts & lemon meringue tarts
Serves 3-4

MINIATURE NEW YEAR'S DECORATED CUPCAKES

$33 Dozen

Silver & gold covered
Serves 3-4

CHOCOLATE DOUBLE SOUFFLÉ CAKE

$38 Each

With chocolate mousse & whipped cream
Serves 6

RASPBERRY & BLUEBERRY TART

$42 Each

With fresh pastry cream
Serves 6

INDIVIDUAL RASPBERRY & BLUEBERRY TART

$9 Each

With fresh pastry cream
Serves 1

STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE

$45 ea.

Layered with fresh cream and berries. 8 Inch.
Serves 8

NEW YEAR'S EVE COOKIE CRATE

$75 Each

Serves 8-12

SEASONAL FRUIT PLATTER

$55 Small

Serves 12-15/Vegan, Gluten-Free

SEASONAL FRUIT PLATTER

$100 Each

Serves 14-20/Vegan, Gluten-Free

We make it simple to order
in only 2 steps

DOWNLOAD

Download and fill out the PDF order sheet.

EMAIL, FAX, CALL-IN

Email a completed order sheet to holiday@butterfieldmarket.com
Fax to (212) 772-2506. or you can call in your order at (212) 772-8782 Ext. 3

ANY QUESTIONS?

If you have any questions, please call us at (212) 772 8782 Ext. 3 or email us at holiday@butterfieldmarket.com

Delivery

We make deliveries throughout Manhattan. Please call us for information on delivery requests outside of the areas listed below

Uptown East
(Between 105-130th)
$30
Upper East Side
(Between 105th & 59th)
$20
Midtown East
(Between 59th & 36th)
$30
Downtown East
(Between 36th & 14th)
$40
Lower East
(Between 14th & Houston Street)
$50
Below Houston East &
Lower West (14th & Houston Street)
$60
Uptown West
(Between 100th -130th)
$40
West Side
(Between 100th and 50th)
$30
Midtown West
(between 59th & 36th)
$40
Downtown West
(30th & 14th Street)
$55
Lower West
(14th & Houston Street)
$60

WHAT PEOPLE ARE SAYING

Popular Questions

When does my order need to be placed?

Orders must be placed by Thursday December 27th at 5PM

Does my food come ready to serve?

Many dishes on our holiday menu need to be heated prior to serving. Check out our serving instructions here.

Can I heat up the food in the containers they are delivered in?

Some items come in aluminum pans which can go directly into the oven. Other items come in plastic containers. Please refer to heating instructions for more detail.

Can I hire waitstaff to help set-up and serve our meal?

Yes of course! Please call and speak to one of our catering coordinators about this service. (212) 772 8782 Ext. 3

Is there a delivery minimum?

No, there is no minimum order required for delivery.

You might also like

PREPARED FOOD MENU

Always fresh, delicious, and enticing. Our prepared food menu changes weekly based on seasonal availability.

View menu

CATERING & EVENTS

Offering a wide variety of catering services to make your next event a tasteful success!

Learn More

FEELING GIFTY?

Butterfield’s signature gift baskets are made and delivered with care.

Shop Now